So my roommate keeps cholov yisroel and therefore only drinks New Square milk. Problem is that for some reason of which I will discuss the milk never lasts more then 3 or 4 days. It is delivered every Thursday to Price Chopper, and then once you buy it it pretty much spoils right away at least compared to my normal milk. My milk lasts at least 10 days sometimes more. So what is the deal?
My roommate thinks that since New Square pretty much has a monopoly in upstate NY cholov yisroel, that they deliberately send bad milk or the almost expired stuff etc… They happen to have a monopoly, because golden flow doesn’t reach the upper reaches of NY beyond Rockland County. Shouldn’t my roomy be dam m’cav zchus?
I thought of another reason. It is a vast conspiracy against Lubavitchers everywhere. You see the Skvere Chasidim like most Chasidim probably hold some grudge against chabadnicks- maybe because the Tanya was widely translated or the whole mechichits thing or maybe because their girls are bunch of hotties. They also know that the only people who use cholov yisroel outside the major metropolitan areas are Lubavitchers. Since all of the Modern non-chasidim hold of Rav Moshe’s sheeta on not having to use cholov yisreol milk nowadays. So maybe its their own little way of getting back at the Lubbies for all the damage doen back in the days of the Alter Rebbe and such.
The real reason is that it is not shipped properly and the Price Chopper people don’t handle it correctly causing it to lose shelf life. Exactly one day is lost for every hour milk is kept out of the fridge. So this teaches us that it is important not to jump to conclusions and always give people the benefit of the doubt.
frum-raid
-06002006-12-27T13:37:39-06:00312006b-06:00Wed, 27 Dec 2006 13:37:39 -0600 5, 206
I live in Brooklyn and formerly drank chalav stam. It is incredible how fast the cholov yisroel milk spoils. This happens whether I get it from shoprite or local supermarkets. I think it is more than the way the milk is handled by the stores. Also, have you noticed how golden flow has an expiration date a few dates later than every other milk (including chalav stam). weird stuff.
frumbutwithit
-06002006-12-27T14:04:29-06:00312006b-06:00Wed, 27 Dec 2006 14:04:29 -0600 5, 206
That is so interesting because we were speculating that since there are only two companies and they have a monopoly why take the extra time and make it last longer. Maybe they forgo the pasturization process? Or maybe they just feel that Jews wont notice since most folks have ten kids and milk only needs to last 3 days or so. So maybe its a conspiracy aginst those who only have 3 kids or none at all?
So I guess we have to rule at that since its shipped to Albany it goes bad- since you have just confirmed that in Brooklyn it goes bad just as fast. Thank you for the comment
deeni
-06002006-12-28T01:39:23-06:00312006b-06:00Thu, 28 Dec 2006 01:39:23 -0600 5, 206
We drink regular milk but the few times we bought chalav yisroel (in brooklyn) it AlWAYS went bad within two days and sometimes didn’t smell great when we opened it. We thought it was the plastic container vs the cardboard for the regular milk.
frumbutwithit
-06002006-12-28T09:47:17-06:00312006b-06:00Thu, 28 Dec 2006 09:47:17 -0600 5, 206
Well problem is that I drink regular milk in the same container that my roommate drinks his cholov yisroel milk in- so it cant the containers. It might turn out to be some sort of monopoly thing. Because they know they can get away with it